For those in the city, a few high-end markets secure small allocations of the harvest:
Located in Southold, this is a staple for North Fork seafood and historically overflows with local bay scallops when the harvest is good. Braun Seafood Co. OpenCutchogue, NY where to buy peconic bay scallops
Agata & Valentina : This specialty Italian gourmet market has historically carried them at a premium price point (often around $78.99/lb). 💻 Online Seafood Purveyors For those in the city, a few high-end
Peconic Bay 2025 scallop harvest remains poor - The Suffolk Times 💻 Online Seafood Purveyors Peconic Bay 2025 scallop
If you are local to Long Island or planning a trip to the North or South Forks, these established seafood markets are your best bet for fresh, day-boat Peconic Bay scallops: Southold Fish Market OpenSouthold, NY
Based in Cutchogue, they operate one of the largest seafood operations on the North Fork and supply both retail customers and local restaurants. Clamman Seafood Market Caterer OpenSouthampton, NY
Haskell's Seafood : Known for selling them under the trademarked name "Peconic Gold," they offer online shipping depending on seasonal availability.