: A common critique is that the younger cast’s humor feels "corny" or more aligned with a Disney Channel sitcom rather than the edgier tone of That '70s Show .

: While some enjoy the throwback references to dial-up internet and Zima, others feel the 1990s setting is "incidental" or purely cosmetic compared to how much the original show leaned into its era.

is widely considered a "nostalgia-heavy" sequel that captures the cozy vibe of the original series while struggling to find its own unique identity . Reviewers generally agree that the show is most successful when it focuses on returning legends Red (Kurtwood Smith) and Kitty (Debra Jo Rupp), whose performances are often cited as the highlight of the series. Mixed Critical Reception