Some viewers felt that certain S1E17 installments, like Star Trek: TNG’s " When the Bough Breaks ," were frustrating due to "irresponsible" plot resolutions:
: The crew is trapped on a planet by a flamboyant, childish being who treats them like toys for his amusement. [S1E17] Episode
“I don't like this episode. From minor things like the all-too-obedient kids, to HUGE things like the horrifying Aldeans, and the impossibly fast and downright irresponsible resolution...” Reddit · r/StarTrekViewingParty · 11 years ago Some viewers felt that certain S1E17 installments, like
This episode leans into a darker, more macabre tone than the series’ usual "freak of the week" formula. “While I have never been a huge fan of the "funny" Combat
“While I have never been a huge fan of the "funny" Combat! episodes, " The Squad " (S1, E17), is clearly the exception. It is the perfect blend of serious AND funny...” Facebook · Combat! · 10 months ago
: Critics noted that while it avoided wallowing in grief, it felt a bit like "life moved on" too quickly. The episode provides strong character development, though some viewers found the "soap opera" drama in Jackson’s personal life to be a bit sappy. Star Trek: The Original Series — " The Squire of Gothos "