The film features several notable performances that contribute to its "heartwarming" atmosphere:
: The owner of the local "Mistletoe Restaurant". Return to Christmas Creek (TV Movie 2018) - IMDb
: Amelia's childhood friend and love interest. Return to Christmas Creek
: Amelia reunites with her estranged uncle, Harry, who runs a local inn. She hasn't seen him in over 20 years due to a mysterious falling out between him and her father.
: Amelia's guarded but well-meaning uncle and charter pilot. She hasn't seen him in over 20 years
: A focused CEO seeking holiday inspiration.
: While in town, she helps Uncle Harry prepare his airplane for his annual tradition of dropping toys for children in a neighbouring town. : While in town, she helps Uncle Harry
: Amelia reconnects with her childhood best friend, Mike Ruggles. As they spend more time together, their relationship evolves into a potential romance.