Most reviewers agree it is much larger and longer than the first chapter, featuring more variety in its puzzles and mini-games.

The game leans into a "mad scientist" or sci-fi vibe rather than purely paranormal horror. Critics argue the jumpscares are predictable and the environment lacks a truly unsettling atmosphere.

The puzzles are frequently criticized for being tedious or unintuitive. Some sections, like the "Banbaleena classroom," are particularly polarizing, with some finding them unique and others calling them a "slog".

“A huge improvement from the first one, but became even goofier... it made it even more enjoyable cuz of the goofiness.” Reddit · r/gartenofbanban · 3 years ago Platform Ratings (approximate)

Reviews for Garten of Banban 2 are highly polarized, often categorized as either a "so bad it's good" guilty pleasure or a lackluster cash-grab . While many players appreciate it as a significant step up from the first game in terms of content and length, critics and enthusiasts of the horror genre often find its gameplay tedious and its production quality low. Core Feedback