Originally operating as a family-owned business, Buy Right Cars became a significant player in Auckland’s competitive car market. The acquisition by Turners was part of a larger strategic shift toward retail-focused growth. The deal, valued at approximately plus inventory, eventually led to the rebranding of the chain under the Turners name.

By 2019, Turners completed a brand write-off of as the "Buy Right Cars" name was officially phased out. This transition was marked by significant legal tension; Orlandini eventually sued Turners in the High Court, claiming he was forced out of the business in a way that prevented him from achieving agreed-upon earnouts. Customer Experiences and Advocacy

: In one notable case from 2012, the brand was ordered to refund a buyer after a manager claimed that crash damage and dents were actually "design features".

Throughout its history, the brand was a frequent subject for consumer watchdogs like .